Current Issues of Legal Cooperation with EU Member States within the Framework of the Hague Convention

Since June 1, 2007, the Hague Convention on "Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction" has been in force for the Republic of Armenia. Currently, there are 93 participating countries in the Hague Convention, which, however, does not imply legal cooperation among these countries.

Within the framework of the Convention, countries need to be classified into two groups: countries that are members of the Hague Conference on Private International Law during its fourteenth session, and other countries. The first group of countries has a privileged status, as their participation in the Convention is limited to its signing.
In the case of the second group of countries, the consent of each participating country is necessary, as according to Article 38 of the Convention, the accession of a country to the Convention is only effective in relations between the Contracting States that declare their consent to that accession. Any Participating State that has ratified, accepted, or approved the Convention after such accession also makes such a declaration.
 
Currently, the Convention is applicable for Armenia in relations with 41 participants, not even including neighboring Georgia in the scope of cooperation.
 
Moreover, the application of the Convention is currently almost impossible even in relations with those European countries that have given their consent to Armenia's accession to the Convention.
 
This particularly concerns the countries included in the European Union and the Schengen Area. Although they have all ratified the Hague Convention, the fact that some member countries have not yet given their consent to Armenia's accession to the Convention (for example, Austria, Bulgaria, Greece, the Netherlands, etc.) makes the application of the Convention impossible even in relations with countries that have given their consent.
 
For a parent with EU citizenship, the Maastricht Treaty (officially, the Treaty on European Union) and for a parent without EU citizenship, the Schengen Agreement have created the legal basis for freely crossing the borders of the countries included in this area, which has made the movement of a parent from a consenting country to a non-consenting country uncontrollable.
 
Countries that are parties to the Schengen Agreement, with the exception of four countries, are simultaneously members of the European Union. In relations with the exception countries—Norway, Iceland, and Switzerland—the Convention is applicable, which means that the consent of all EU member countries to Armenia's accession will significantly facilitate the application of the Convention in the EU area.
 
Considering the importance of the issue, the significant flow from Armenia to EU member countries, and the necessity to be governed by common rules in the European Union, the EU Council decided in 2011 (2011/0452 (NLE)) on the necessity of notifying member countries about the consent to Armenia's accession to the Hague Convention. This decision caused dissatisfaction among several member countries, thereby somewhat prolonging the already time-consuming process of resolving the issue.
 
Referring to Article 38 of the Hague Convention, they argue that the right to express consent for a country to join the Convention is reserved for the Contracting States. Giving consent implies the mutual rights and obligations assumed by the countries that have joined the Convention and those that have expressed their consent to that accession; therefore, according to them, the consent must be individual in nature and express the will of the respective subjects in each case.
 
The Court of Justice of the European Union has also expressed its opinion on the matter, considering the exclusive competence of the European Union regarding the decision to express consent for Armenia's accession to the Hague Convention, citing Article 3 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.
 
The next step in this lengthy process was the adoption of a resolution by the European Parliament on February 11, 2015, regarding this issue.
 
It should be noted that this process, which started in 2011, may take even years, which speaks to the necessity of addressing the gaps in domestic legislation that contribute to "parental abductions."
To resolve the issue, it is necessary to amend the Government Decision No. 735-N of May 12, 2011, on establishing the border regime at the state border of the Republic of Armenia and the regime at border crossing points, allowing the crossing of the state border by a minor only with the consent of the absent parent, the presence of a death certificate of the parent, a legally valid court decision recognizing the parent as missing, or notes in the child's birth certificate confirming the fact that the paternity of the child's father has not been established.
 
By acceding to the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the Republic of Armenia has undertaken the obligation to give priority attention to the best interests of the child in all actions concerning children, including those undertaken by the legislative body (in this case, in the legislative process). The current legal regulations do not ensure the best interests of the child, which primarily implies the realization of the right to recognition of parents, and to receive their care and custody, arising from the Convention from the moment of birth.
 
Hasmik Ohnikian
"Ayleks" Law Office
 
link pastinfo.am