The Ilex Law Office is pleased to share its victory at the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Armenia.
On May 19, 2026, the Constitutional Court, in decision SDO-1828, recognized as unconstitutional and invalid the third part of Article 234.4 and the first part of Article 361 of the Civil Procedure Code of the Republic of Armenia, to the extent that they did not provide for the possibility of appealing protective decisions through the process of review. The crucial issue was raised in the Constitutional Court by attorney Hasmik Ohnikian on behalf of the Applicant.
The constitutional application concerned the interpretation given in legal practice to Article 361 of the Civil Procedure Code, which resulted in individuals being deprived of the opportunity to appeal protective decisions that restricted their constitutional rights, solely on the grounds that the mentioned article did not directly provide for the appeal of such judicial acts.
Although protective decisions were not directly included in the list of judicial acts subject to appeal in the review process under the first part of Article 361 of the Code, this list was not exhaustive. In particular, point 15 of the first part of the same article also provided for the possibility of appealing other decisions in cases specified by law.
At the same time, the seventh part of Article 8 of the Law of the Republic of Armenia on "Prevention of Family and Domestic Violence and Protection of Persons Subjected to Family and Domestic Violence" stipulated that the procedure for appealing protective decisions is provided by the Civil Procedure Code of the Republic of Armenia.
Therefore, the contested legal regulation could not be interpreted in isolation, without considering other laws regulating relevant legal relations and the right to effective judicial protection guaranteed by the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia. It should be interpreted in light of the purpose pursued by the legislator and the constitutional guarantees for the protection of fundamental human rights.
At the time of filing the constitutional application, the non-appealability of protective decisions was not merely a consequence of a legislative gap. The Supreme Court of Armenia had already established a legal position in its decision of November 1, 2023, according to which protective decisions were not subject to appeal in the review process.
An important part of the arguments presented in the application was also the necessity of ensuring procedural rights in the context of the urgency of examining cases regarding protective decisions. As is known, these cases are examined without convening a court session according to the existing legal regulations, and the respondent is given a three-day period to submit a written response after receiving the application.
In such a procedure, proper notification and the real opportunity to present arguments and evidence become particularly important. If a person is not properly notified about the examination of the case, they may effectively be deprived of their only fundamental procedural opportunity for defense. Moreover, if the judicial act issued under such conditions is also not subject to appeal, the possibility of correcting potential judicial errors of the first instance court is directly absent.
Protective decisions have consequences that restrict constitutional rights. Especially in family relations, the loss of time can lead to consequences that cannot be fully restored even later when the violation of rights is recognized. For example, relationships disrupted due to prolonged restrictions on contact between a parent and a child are not always successfully restored. In this sense, it is crucial that the legal remedy is practically effective and timely accessible.
Thus, the Constitutional Court, in its decision SDO-1828 of May 19, 2026, stated that the absence of the possibility to appeal protective decisions through the review process does not comply with the requirements of the first part of Article 61 and Article 75 of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia.
This decision is important not only for those individuals against whom protective measures are applied. It is also significant for individuals seeking protective measures through the adoption of a protective decision, as the right to appeal a judicial act should ensure the possibility of reviewing both the legality of the applied restrictions and the judicial act rejecting or partially satisfying the request for protection.
20.05.2026
