Below are the clarifications of lawyer Hasmik Ohnikyan regarding gender-based pregnancy termination.
-The government approved a package of legislative proposals in the previous session, which suggests prohibiting pregnancy termination based on the child's gender. How do you assess the proposed changes?
-In essence, under the current legal regulations, artificial termination of pregnancy based on the child's gender is not permitted. Without revealing the motives for pregnancy termination, it is only allowed up to the 12th week of pregnancy, meaning during the period when the child's gender is not yet clearly identified by the parents.
From the 12th to the 22nd week of pregnancy, artificial termination is only permissible for medical or social reasons, the exhaustive list of which is defined by the relevant government decision. During this period, artificial termination of pregnancy for other reasons, including gender-based reasons, is considered illegal. I believe that in this regard, the project simply aims to clarify the current legal regulation by directly enshrining a norm-prohibition.
-Although you mention that gender-based pregnancy termination is currently not permitted by law, we cannot deny that they are practically carried out. In this regard, will the legal definition of a direct prohibition change the current reality?
-The project proposes to establish a written procedure for artificial termination of pregnancy, as well as administrative liability for those responsible who do not comply with the requirements of the procedure. In the case of pregnancy termination between the 12th and 22nd weeks, carrying out the artificial termination without a medical commission's decision will also lead to administrative liability. The aforementioned reforms proposed by the project will increase the controllability of the process.
The project also proposes to establish the obligation of the doctor to provide free consultation to the pregnant woman regarding the possible negative consequences of the medical intervention before it is carried out. The fact of being warned must be confirmed by the signature of the pregnant woman. Such a requirement for the law not only serves the interests of the pregnant woman but also is necessary for the proper fulfillment of the state's international obligations in the field of human rights. The European Court of Human Rights noted a violation of the Convention in the case of X v. Romania for the failure of the state to ensure the realization of a woman's right to be informed about the possible negative consequences of artificial termination of pregnancy.
-What issues do citizens approach lawyers with regarding pregnancy termination?
-In my professional practice, only two cases related to artificial termination of pregnancy have been registered. In both cases, the applicants were spouses undergoing divorce proceedings who wanted to prevent the actions of the wife intending to terminate the pregnancy artificially. In this regard, I must note that, as in many countries around the world, in our country, the father of the future child does not have any legal leverage to influence or prevent the woman's decision.
-Isn't that a legislative gap?
-There is no unanimous opinion among lawyers on this issue. In most Muslim countries, including Egypt and Turkey, artificial termination of pregnancy is not allowed without the husband's consent. In our case, the fact of being in divorce proceedings is even considered a social indicator, therefore it is one of the grounds on which the legislator allows artificial termination of pregnancy even after the 12th week. The lack of reservation of the right of the future child's father to influence the decision has been repeatedly challenged in the European Court, citing Articles 2 and 8 of the Convention. To date, the court has not recorded any violation of the rights of the future child's father in any case examined. Although in all examined cases, artificial termination of pregnancy was based on medical indications, the combination of positions expressed in various decisions allows us to conclude that the European Court exclusively prioritizes the will of the pregnant woman in the decision-making process regarding artificial termination of pregnancy. My personal opinion in this regard does not coincide with the opinions of those lawyers who do not prioritize the rights of the future child's father in the decision-making process regarding artificial termination of pregnancy not based on medical indications.
-Finally, returning to the prohibition of gender-based pregnancy termination, do you not think that it, nevertheless, interferes with the personal life of parents?
-At first glance, the establishment of a norm-prohibition indeed implies an interference in the personal life of the parent carrying the child, but it does not necessarily mean that the interference violates the fundamental right of the parent to respect for their private life.
The right to respect for private and family life is enshrined in Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which simultaneously defines the obligation of states not to interfere with everyone's exercise of that right. However, it should be noted that the right to respect for one's private and family life can be limited by the Convention, provided that such limitation pursues certain legitimate and public interests, is necessary in a democratic society, and is necessarily provided by law.
Enshrining a norm prohibiting artificial termination of pregnancy based on the child's gender in the law was a necessity from the perspective of ensuring the requirements of Article 8 of the Convention.
Regarding the pursued legitimate purpose, it should be noted that gender-based artificial terminations of pregnancy may lead to a decrease in the number of girls in the population and, as a consequence, a decrease in birth rates in the republic. In fact, the interference in personal life by the state pursues legitimate purposes, therefore it is a necessity in a democratic society, and if clearly enshrined in law, it will not lead to violations of women's rights.
